When Claudia and Chris Beiler determined to maneuver this yr, they didn’t draw back from fixer-uppers. The couple owns a house design and renovation firm in Honey Brook, Pa., a borough on the border of the Philadelphia suburbs and the Pennsylvania Dutch Nation, the place each of their households have roots.
They’d additionally spent practically 12 years slowly renovating the three-bedroom home in Honey Brook the place they have been elevating their quickly rising household, which now consists of 5 sons between the ages of two and 10. Mr. Beiler did a lot of the restoration work on the 1870 brick home himself, whereas Mrs. Beiler dealt with the décor, a mixture of trendy and classic. They turned the attic into an residence and rented it out by way of Airbnb.
[Did you recently buy a home? We want to hear from you. Email: thehunt@nytimes.com. Sign up here to have The Hunt delivered to your inbox every week.]
“We actually liked the city, and actually felt like we have been presupposed to be there with the folks,” mentioned Mrs. Beiler, 34. “However the extra youngsters we had, the extra we simply felt actually crowded there.”
For his or her new dwelling, the couple aimed to remain inside half-hour of Honey Brook, the place they’d hold their previous home and hire it out to mates.
Mrs. Beiler, who homeschools the youngsters, wished sufficient area for a classroom and several other acres of land so they may “run and roam and catch snakes.” She additionally wished a home with a midcentury or “cool” trendy fashion, although choices within the space have been restricted.
“It’s very, very uncommon to discover a midcentury dwelling in Lancaster County, as a result of we’re extra farmhouse,” she mentioned. “We’re very colonial fashion.”
Mr. Beiler, 40, works as an actual property agent with Mrs. Beiler’s father, and dealt with the deal. The couple knew that the majority massive homes with numerous land close by would wish critical repairs as a result of the world’s Amish patrons, who usually have massive households and gardens, “often snap up properties that measurement shortly,” Mrs. Beiler mentioned. Those which can be left are usually in rougher form.
The Beilers discovered three houses that supplied the indoor and outside area they sought. Every had at the very least one main flaw that may value quite a bit to repair, however due to their expertise with renovations, they have been keen to think about virtually something.
“We have been hoping to spend lower than $800,000 to $850,000 on the value of the house and any prices and crucial renovations for shifting in,” Mr. Beiler mentioned.

This four-bedroom, three-bath, 3,417-square-foot ranch home sat on practically 4 acres in a hilly Honey Brook subdivision, and it got here with an undeveloped lot subsequent door. The L-shaped home had some inside prospers that felt midcentury-modern, like a floor-to-ceiling stone hearth, an open floorplan and many home windows and skylights. However it was in worse form than the itemizing pictures prompt, and it additionally had mould. There was a two-car storage, a completed basement with a toilet, two decks, and a pool that wanted intensive repairs. The worth was $565,000, with about $7,700 in annual taxes. Mr. Beiler estimated it wanted about $200,000 value of renovations.


This three-bedroom, two-bath, 2,692-square-foot dwelling in Elverson, Pa., was constructed into the facet of a grassy hill, permitting folks to stroll onto the highest of the home itself. Inside, arched home windows and a spiral staircase gave it a particular look, however all the things was dated, from the kitchen to the bogs to the wall-to-wall carpeting. There have been two bedrooms on the primary flooring, and a living-family room with doorways to a deck on the second flooring. The connected three-car storage got here with an R.V. inside. The home additionally had mould, each in and out. The four-acre plot had expansive countryside views, however few timber, which means numerous visibility of neighboring houses. It was listed at $350,000, with taxes of about $7,000. Mr. Beiler estimated it wanted about $300,000 in repairs.


This four-bedroom, three-bath, 2,940-square-foot midcentury-modern dwelling was hidden on a wooded, 13-acre plot in Morgantown, Pa. It had a lot of its authentic mahogany woodwork, in addition to vaulted ceilings with skylights, stone fireplaces and a basement rec room. Outdoors have been a lined patio, a three-car storage, a horse barn and a pool with a sauna. The earlier house owners, an Amish household, had stripped out many of the electrical techniques and plumbing, relying as a substitute on an outside wood-burning furnace. Consequently, the Beilers wouldn’t even be capable to get a standard financial institution mortgage to purchase the home. It was listed at $786,800, with taxes of round $5,300. Mr. Beiler estimated the full value of renovations to be about $100,000.

Discover out what occurred subsequent by answering these two questions: